Well, the time has finally come. Our white Pottery Barn sofa—originally found on Craigslist many years ago—has reached the end of its life. It served us well for a long time, and I’ve written often about both my love for white slipcovers and the realities of living with them. So here’s an updated installment of The Truth About White Slipcovers.
Below are the main reasons our white sofa didn’t last forever.
Those sweet, fluffy members of our family played a big role. When I first wrote about white slipcovers we only had our dog Winston (who passed away a year and a half ago). Since then we added Jack, Lily, and their cousin Bella.
I still love white slipcovers and always will. They helped us through our son’s young years and through the challenges of caring for older pets. They were worth the effort, but they weren’t always easy to maintain.
To be honest, it wouldn’t have mattered if the slipcovers were tan or another color—I don’t want gross stains on any furniture. White at least lets me wash and, when necessary, bleach the covers. But white is still white.
We tried rules—no dogs on the furniture—but eventually I was outnumbered. With an older sofa I worried less about damage, and the quilts I draped on the cushions to protect them often ended up on the floor anyway. Who knew pups could toss blankets off a couch?
As the number of dogs grew, so did the wear on the sofa. This summer it reached an all-time low.
When a dog ate some grass and vomited on the sofa a couple of weeks ago and I didn’t notice for two days, I reached the limit of my tolerance. It wasn’t about giving up entirely, but I was done washing another slipcover. I could have cleaned and bleached everything and made it usable again, but the ongoing effort wasn’t something I wanted to keep repeating. Winter brings mud, and I didn’t want to commit to that cycle anymore.
The pups don’t mean to be destructive. They’re all under three and a half years old—energetic, affectionate, and playful. They run in and out of the sliding door that’s right by the sofa, often tracking muddy paws straight onto the cushions.
For a long time this was manageable. That’s why I wasn’t a constantly stressed dog owner: the slipcovers were washable and bleachable, and they were a practical solution for a busy family with pets. Over the years I even bought replacement slipcovers to extend the sofa’s life.
But because we had so many pups and I was washing the slipcovers so often, I grew weary of the upkeep. For a while I stopped washing them in rebellion, which made things worse—either the covers were filthy or the sofa went bare. I couldn’t relax and sit comfortably, and that’s not how I want to live. I like a clean home and I want to use my furniture.
The sofa gave us many happy years. Because we bought it used, it lasted even longer than most. But it’s time for it to move on so I can enjoy my living room again. I’ll miss those white slipcovers, but I’m excited to try something new that takes less constant maintenance. The dogs will still get muddy and silly—that’s life—but for now my white slipcover days are over.
Update: See the couch I chose!
Shop my house and favorite furniture and decor here!
Follow all of our doodles on Instagram.