Bedroom Paint Color Indecision
Hello friends. In the four years we’ve lived in this house, our bedroom has evolved slowly and organically. Nothing was planned all at once—just small updates over time as we’ve lived here.
We’ve rearranged furniture, added curtains, switched out bedding and rugs, changed the light fixture, found our dream bed on Facebook Marketplace (still so happy about that!), and even installed new floors when we had the downstairs redone. The floors made a surprisingly big difference. Bit by bit, the room keeps changing.
Lately we’ve been talking about finally painting the walls. We haven’t touched them since we moved in. We like the current color (it was here when we moved in, called Bunny Gray by Benjamin Moore), but it definitely needs a fresh coat.
So now we’re in the “what color should we paint it?” phase—the fun and somehow most impossible part. Why is choosing paint so hard?
Since the bed, in a lovely robin’s egg blue-green, is staying, that’s our starting point. We want a wall color that complements it—something that works with our floors and natural light (the room faces northwest and gets a bit of morning sun)—but doesn’t compete with the bed.
If we were tackling a bigger project, I’d be tempted by wallpaper or creamy white tongue-and-groove paneling; both would look beautiful with the bed. For now, paint feels like the simplest and most practical next step—something we can do without turning it into a large, expensive renovation.
We always seem to come back to blue for this room. Whenever we consider other directions, like a soft neutral or a muted green, it never quite feels right. There’s something about blue that makes the space feel calm and cheerful.
To me, how a room feels is just as important as how it looks.
I considered green, but because the bed already has a greenish tint, blue offers a softer, prettier contrast. Yellows, soft neutrals, browns, rusts, salmons, or pinks could also be pretty, but none of them have landed as the right fit—yet.
A creamy white paneled wall would be my dream, but that’s likely for another time. For now, we’re testing blues and will explore other options if none of them feel right.
We want a color that’s cozy without feeling dreary—enough depth to make the bed stand out, but not so dark that the room feels heavy.
The challenge is that many blues we like are very close in tone to the bed. I don’t mind a tonal look, but I don’t want the bed to disappear. I’ve sampled Wales Gray, Eventide, and a shade called Morning at Sea—this last one is a deeper blue that caught my eye. It might be brighter than I expect, but in other homes it didn’t feel overly bright. Sometimes seeing the color on your own walls is the only way to know.
We’ve also considered lighter blues similar to the current mood, but nothing has felt quite right so far. I imagine the room as a happy beach cottage, though because it’s small it could benefit from a slightly moodier “NW beach cottage” tone.
I also thought about Beach Glass, a soothing shade we already used in the living room. I’m unsure if it would be different enough from the bed, but it’s worth testing a swatch or two.
As a playful experiment, we asked ChatGPT to render the room in a slightly moodier blue. It didn’t match the bed color exactly and added a new Finnegan, but it was a helpful visualization. I also had it show the room with a black rattan chair, which ties in nicely with our black Chinoiserie cabinet and makes that piece feel more intentional.
I like that mood; if I find the right color this could be a real option. For a fun twist, we also asked for striped walls in shades of blue.
Striking, yes? The other room elements or the exact blue shades could be adjusted, as could the stripe width and contrast if we want something softer.
Nothing in the room has to remain, except the bed—though it’s helpful if some pieces still work with the new color. Surprisingly, my husband loved the idea of stripes. They might not be everyone’s idea of a calming bedroom, but we like a bit of pattern. Stripes can make the room feel layered and cozy, especially as a backdrop behind the bed.
Sometimes patterns do the opposite of what you expect: instead of energizing a space, they can make it feel more settled and snug. Of course, that’s a personal preference, but it’s worth considering. Fortunately, we’ve painted stripes before, so it’s a feasible DIY project.
Here are a few variations and stripe concepts we tried for fun, including one showing the bed in place.
Below is a softer stripe contrast to consider.
It’s fun to vary the colors and see how the mood shifts. I’m also excited to refresh the hallway since it’s visible from the bedroom, so we’ll work on each space over time.
Back to reality—we need to decide. I’ve saved many inspiration photos in different colors and styles, but we can’t use every idea, so it’s time to narrow things down.
I’d love your input. What color or pattern would you choose? Keep the current color? Try something totally different? Go bold with a pattern?
I asked on Instagram stories a while back and got lots of helpful suggestions. Not everyone will love the final choice, and that’s okay—taste varies and it’s hard to know how a color will feel without seeing it in the space.
Hearing other ideas is useful and might reveal options we haven’t considered. If you’d ever like to see what your own space could look like with a few changes, we offer AI room makeovers in our HomeBody community—it’s a fun way to visualize new looks.
Click here for my bedroom sources